The Hangman (1959)

Strictly average movie

recommended

One of the most extraordinary films you will see this year. Take that as you want.

Great example of an old-fashioned, pure-at-heart escapist event movie that doesn't pretend to be anything that it's not and has boat loads of fun being its own ludicrous self.

This could have been a pretty good Western. It had a solid cast with Robert Taylor, Fess Parker, a young Tina Louise (Ginger on Gilligan's Island) and Jack Lord (Hawaii 5-0). The plot was good about a lawman sent to arrest a wanted fugitive for his part in a holdup that ended in murder.And 3/4 of the movie is very enjoyable, solid 7/10 stars. But...Your reaction to this movie is likely to depend upon your answer to three questions:1. Should lawmen ever allow personal feelings affect how they perform their duties? 2. Should lawmen treat suspects differently because they like or dislike them? 3. Is it right for ordinary people to take the law into their own hands if they like or dislike a suspect?If you answered yes to all these questions, you will probably like it. If you answered no to any of them, you will probably not.

This one has a flawlessly-written script by Dudley Nichols, the screenwriter of many well-known movies from 1930 to 1960 such as "Stagecoach" "The Bells of St. Mary's" and "For Whom the Bell Tolls". There's often a good moral lesson to be learned from a screenplay written by Nichols. The original story was by Luke Short, the author of many Western novels. The cast is very good too with Robert Taylor as the "Hangman" Deputy Marshall, and several people who would later become familiar TV stars: Tina Louise, Jack Lord, Fess Parker and briefly, Lorne Green. And of course you can't go wrong with the direction of the great Michael Curtiz ("Casablanca") who, like Nichols, was nearing the end of his career.I especially liked the story, it's deeper than most westerns, as it explores the themes of justice, loyalty, and forgiveness.

Robert Taylor plays a cynical lawman in director Michael Curtiz's offbeat but interesting western "The Hangman" who has a habit of getting his man and bringing him to face justice. Taylor doesn't look like the usual U.S. Deputy Marshal this time around. He dresses business-like in a jacket with his six-gun holstered on his pants' belt well out of sight so he looks like he isn't packing a revolver. Believe it or not, this gruff character in dark apparel starts out as one kind of hombre and ends up as a different one by fadeout. This 1959 black & white western reminded me a little of the Charles Bronson bounty hunter western "Showdown at Boot Hill." Bronson gunned down his quarry, but nobody wanted to pay him off for his work. Similarly, after he delivers one outlaw to be hanged to his immediate superior, Marshal Clum Cummings (soon to be "Bonanza" star Lorne Greene), our hero, Marshal Mackenzie Bovard sets out to track down the last renegade named Jim Butterfield. The only problem that confronts Bovard is that nobody knows what Butterfield looks like except the man who is destined to swing in a week's time for the murder of another deputy. Bovard knows that Butterfield served in the calvary so he rides out to the nearest fort where the outlaw served. Unfortunately, the only man who can identify Butterfield is an orderly (Regis Toomey) but the fort commandant cannot release him to ride with Bovard for at least a month. The orderly recommends that Bovard look up a woman, Selah Jennison (Tina Louise of "The Good Guys and the Bad Guys") because she can recognize him. Bovard offers her $500 in gold if she will follow him to a nearby town and identify Butterfield. Bovard sets out on a stage to that town where he meets up with the town lawman, Sheriff Buck Weston (Fess Parker of "Davy Crockett") and asks around about Butterfield. The most obvious candidate is a well-liked teamster who works for a freighting firm, but he Jim Butterfield (Jack Lord of "Hawaii 5-o") has changed his name to Jim Bishop and nobody knows about his notorious past. Initially, Selah doesn't show up when she is supposed to and Bovard begins to have doubts about his cynical outlook on people. He assures Sheriff Weston that everybody has a price. Meantime, Curtiz and scenarist Dudley Nichols of "Stagecoach" fame struggle to work in some uneven humor. During the stage ride, a mature woman older than Bovard, Amy Hopkins (Mabel Albertson of "The Cobweb") struggles to attract Bovard's attention, but he ignores her. Just as Bovard is about to give up hope that Selah will show up, Selah shows up and Amy is surprised and affronted by her presence. Selah doesn't want to identify Butterfield and sneaks off to warn him. Not even Bovard can convince one of Butterfield's enemies at the teamster firm to testify against him. A harmless Mexican Pedro Alonso (Jose Gonzales-Gonzales of "Rio Bravo") who works alongside Butterfield tries to kill Bovard twice but fails to succeed each time. Eventually, even Bovard relents, turns in his badge, and decides to head for California to live the life that he has always dreamed up. Surprisingly, Selah turns down Sheriff Weston's offer of marriage and accompanies Bovard to California. This is not a terrain western with horsemen charging back and forth across the landscape. Most of the action occurs in a western town. Ironically, Bovard brandishes his revolver, but he doesn't kill anybody. Similarly, director Michael Curtiz doesn't display his usual flair in this Paramount Pictures release.

I like this movie for a number of reasons. The first being it is a Robert Taylor western, which you can always count on to be a good movie.Taylor plays MacKenzie Bovard a feared marshall nicknamed the Hangman because he catches the bad guys and then "the law hangs them". He is after the last of a hold up gang, and this he says is his last job. He has missed out on life and wants to move to California to start again. He persuades Selah Jennison (Tina Louise) to come to town to identify Johnny Butterfield (Jack Lord). She is miserable and alone and eventually goes to town for the money. Bovard is disappointed that she arrives because when she did not show up immediately, he felt he had finally found someone who could not be bought. He treats her badly, but still feels something there. She is much younger in years but is loyal to Butterfield. When she goes to Johnny to warn him, Bovard follows her and a friend of Johnny's ambushes him, shooting him. Selah goes back to her room and is confronted by an angry Bovard, wounded and unhappy that he could have ever thought she was something different. She tries to make him believe that she is concerned only for him, but he rejects her. The next morning she awakes to find Bovard in her bed, and handcuffed to him. He tracks down Johnny with Selah still handcuffed to him, a good comic twist to a serious story. In the end Bovard shoots above Johnny's head and lets him escape. The sheriff, Fess Parker is in love with Selah and has asked her to marry him, but she rejects the proposal and goes to California with Bovard to start a new life. Taylor is great as the cynical lawman, who in the end finds that a young woman knows more of loyalty and love than he could have ever imagined. Tina Louise is good as the girl, and has some good scenes with Taylor, quite touching one minute and argumentative the next. Good western, and the first independent film Taylor made outside the MGM studio system.