Midnight Shadow (1939)

Plot so thin, it passes unnoticed.

Intense, gripping, stylish and poignant

Boring, long, and too preachy.

It's a mild crowd pleaser for people who are exhausted by blockbusters.

Midnight Shadow (1939) ** (out of 4) Margaret Wilson (Frances Redd) has a couple men wanting her affections but after her father shows off an oil well to them, he's murdered. Now the two men are suspects so the daughter hires a private detective to figure out who the killer is.MIDNIGHT SHADOW stands out because of its all black cast but sadly outside of this there's really nothing too special here. This film follows the "old dark house" theme that ran thought hundreds of films from this period but the majority of the horror elements are watered down in favor of the detective story, which is obviously watered down even more by the attempt at laughter. As with many films, this one goes for laughs as the detective and his assistant share insults and comic falls but this doesn't really work.I was surprised to see how good the majority of the lead performances were. This includes Redd who was quite believable in the role of the daughter. There are some weak performances to be found in smaller parts but nothing too damaging to the film. I also thought the actual mystery was well-done and at least keeps you guessing a little. MIDNIGHT SHADOW is a fair thriller that will mainly appeal to those wanting to see an example of an all black cast.

Comedy mystery with an all-black cast (not pertaining to rugby), with the daughter of a wealthy landowner (Redd) being wooed by the charismatic but suspicious circus mentalist and apparent sub-continent royal heir (Criner), before her father is murdered and deeds to an oil-rich plot of land stolen during the night. Two bumbling detectives join forces with the police to catch the killer whom they believe will attempt to cash-in the stolen land deed, employing their unique brand of detective skills to solve the mystery and claim the kudos.Swiftly told tale suffers for its amateurish acting (many times do the cast appear to lose character and look off-stage for direction), but also a curiously erratic narrative that never settles whether it's comedy or mystery. Perhaps it's both, and if so, it's a period piece in which the only recognisable face (to me) was Ruby Daindridge in a minor supporting role playing the mother of a bookish novice detective (Bates) who looks and behaves like the Chris Rock of his era.Classified as a "race" film, it might be worth seeking if you're a film historian, but there's little else to recommend it to mainstream audiences, with a poorly conceived plot, some truly abominable acting and at times, painfully laboured dialogue.

This isn't as bad a film as some of the reviewers imply. "Race" movie productions had budgets that made Monogram look like MGM. Considering many of the players weren't professional actors - half the cast of "Midnight Shadow" only appeared in one or two movies at the most and those that did appear in more main stream movies, were mostly in uncredited, demeaning roles. Many of the cast seemed to handle their roles in a natural manner (ie Ollie Ann Robinson and Jess Lee Brooks) although a couple looked like a deer caught in the headlights (Frances Redd, who was a model and not an actress anyway.) There was no need for a musical interlude in this film as it was just a regular "who done it" and moved along briskly. These films were made for black audiences and tried to depict stories about everyday situations (not always about witch doctors and voodoo etc).When a well respected business man turns up dead, suspicion falls on his daughter's two suitors. They happen to be in the house when Margaret's father brings out his oil well deeds and both act suspiciously. The first suitor calls himself "The Great Prince Alihabad" and impresses Margaret's mother (Ollie Ann Robinson) as being shifty. The second is Buster (Edward Brandon) who has a very "hang dog" expression - Margaret (Frances Redd) is very fickle and is giving him the run around. In the synopsis that accompanied this DVD it said "Margaret decides to track down the killer herself with the aid of two bumbling private eyes". That is completely false. Margaret wasn't in it much to begin with and almost disappeared during the last half of the movie. The bumbling private eyes were in it however. Lightfoot and Junior Lingley (who is allowed to help out at his mother's (Ruby Dandridge) insistence). There was a funny exchange between them - "I let you get the dope on this case" "I didn't know it was a dope case" "Not that type of dope"!!! They do crack the case at the end - it is not who anyone would think!!! and they do have some interesting scenes with Sgt. Ramsey (an outstanding Jess Lee Brooks) at the end.These films were important. At a time when most white audiences thought Stepin Fetchit was a very real portrait of the Afro American character, "race" movies attempted to show black people as they really were.

1st watched 9/15/2001 - 4 out of 10(Dir-George Randol): Mostly badly acted mystery involving the murder of a man in a black community. Besides the antics of a couple of funny detectives this is otherwise a very uninteresting film. It does have some merit because it was a complete black production from an age where blacks were only given small and very predictable characters in the white-owned film world of the day. This film wouldn't have broken the barrier even if it was made by a big budget film maker because of the very simple story. I am glad that this has been put to video just for a historical reason if for nothing else and to give us a different perspective on this culture in these times.