The Man with Two Faces (1934)

Tied for the best movie I have ever seen

Fantastic!

A lot of perfectly good film show their cards early, establish a unique premise and let the audience explore a topic at a leisurely pace, without much in terms of surprise. this film is not one of those films.

Strong acting helps the film overcome an uncertain premise and create characters that hold our attention absolutely.

This one I knew wasn't going to a ground breaking film from the 30's but I saw that Edward G. Robinson was in it so I had to watch it. I didn't live back in the 30's but I can bet that even back then no one would believe the basic plot line in this one. Totally ridiculous.The premise is that an actress is coming back from a lengthy illness/sabbatical. She has a successful turn at her first acting in a play in a while and it's a success. Her brother is almost done with acting but does the play because she's in it. He loves her. The issue is she has a nefarious husband who's life is to make everyone's life around worse by doing one thing....hypnotizing them. The reason his wife was "away" because he has an overpowering effect on her and she needed to get away from him. Luckily, he got jail time so she had time to recuperate.When you first see this guys character come into play and hearing his first lines and his demeanor you can't help but laugh. It's so stupid. Can you imagine? Someone who can hypnotize most around him or that his over bearing personality can make people do whatever he wants. I mean as soon as we see him, his wife goes back into the trance like state. It's just beyond unbelievable. Of course there are a few who don't buy it and one is her brother (Edward G). He prepares a detailed plan to get him out of there life. I won't go into detail with that part because it's actually pretty good.The reason why this film barely works is because Edwar G. Robinson saves it. He's such a good actor he could have made Plan 9 from Outer Space a decent "B" film. He brings such ability to the screen you believe in what he portrays. The ending is quite good and I'm sure you'll agree. I would have given this film a higher rating but the basic plot point is so stupid I just couldn't.Watch this when your bored on a Saturday afternoon and be prepared to watch a plot that's right out of a Soap Opera.

If this film has a weak spot it's the story's details. Without giving anything away the whole idea of Vance's (Calhern) Svengali-like hypnotic effect on his wife (Astor) is a bit far-fetched, even for 1934. And quite frankly Robinson's disguise left a lot to be desired. And let's not forget the clue that clinched the policeman's case. I can't imagine building a case of such flimsy evidence. There's other areas of concern but I digress. Now for the good part: where the film shines is in the performances. This bevy of fine actors does a most excellent job at presenting complex characters driven by events not of their own choosing. It's a pretty talky film but I didn't mind in the least. The dialog is spirited, lively, expressive. And the performers tended to make me forget the plot's weak points. They were captivating, all of them, Robinson, Astor, Calhern, Cortez (in a rare good guy part), and last but not least, Mae Clarke, in my opinion a most underrated actor.

This movie is a nice little gem, mainly for the witty dialog and impressive rank of actors who clearly enjoyed their work. No surprise there -- just look at the writers, source material and cast. Even the supporting players had great lines that they delivered with gusto. None of it is very realistic, but the set-up is great, much of the acting is over-the-top fun, and there is a great deal of humor. The finale is interesting -- it won't please everyone, but it is even-handed -- both pre-code and code aspects. See it and you will know what I mean. Incidentally, as another reviewer here noted, the TV Guide review (you have to go to the TV Guide website to see it) is WRONG about important parts of the plot and especially the ending. It is as though their reviewer did not see the movie!

This 1934 film had a cast of movie legends along with Edward G. Robinson (Damon Welles) who also starred in "The Red House" and hundreds of other films. Mary Astor (Jessica Welles),who starred in "The Maltese Falcon" '41 with Humphrey Bogart. Even Mae Clarke (Daphne Martin) who was on "General Hospital '63 TV Series as Marge. Louis Calhern(Stanley Vance) played a nasty con-artist in this picture and was dispised by everyone, even Damon Welles. Louis Calhern starred in "Asphalt Jungle" 1950 along with Marilyn Monroe and had a long career in the 1920's to late 1960's. In 1934, this was considered a great drama or mystery, unfortunately, the plot was very poor, but the Actors made this a True Film Classic.