Bathing Beauty (1944)

I like movies that are aware of what they are selling... without [any] greater aspirations than to make people laugh and that's it.

n my opinion it was a great movie with some interesting elements, even though having some plot holes and the ending probably was just too messy and crammed together, but still fun to watch and not your casual movie that is similar to all other ones.

It’s an especially fun movie from a director and cast who are clearly having a good time allowing themselves to let loose.

It’s not bad or unwatchable but despite the amplitude of the spectacle, the end result is underwhelming.

Esther Williams' first starring role is a silly but fun musical comedy from MGM filmed in beautiful Technicolor. Despite the title the movie centers more on Red Skelton's character, a songwriter who marries then loses Esther because of the machinations of Basil Rathbone. So Red forces his way into enrollment at the all-girls college where Esther is a teacher, hoping to win her back. It's all fluff but enjoyable. Musical numbers by the Xavier Cugat Orchestra, Harry James and His Music Makers, Lina Romay, Helen Forrest, and more. The music's fine and Red's funny but Esther's the reason most of us are likely to watch this. She's gorgeous, of course, and has a nice swimming scene at the beginning and a classic aquatic ballet number at the end. Just amazing to watch. She's very likable and holds her own with Skelton. It's easy to see how this movie made her a star. The cast also includes Carlos Ramirez, Nana Bryant, Donald Meek, Jean Porter, Jacqueline Dalya, and Janis Paige (in her film debut). Basil Rathbone seems to be having fun with a different kind of part than he usually got to play. Yeah he's sort of the villain but it's a soft villainy not someone evil. He gets to do a little comedy, too, which he seemed to enjoy. It goes on a little longer than it needed to but it's all light and fun. The sort of movie that's a good pick-me-up when you're feeling down.

You know this is a comedy that lives in the slapstick category of humor when a bicycle built for four, ridden by three coeds and a guitarist, comes out of a closet. Before that, you might guess that the humor borders on the absurd when you realize the steamy romantic relationship the film revolves around is between Esther Williams and Red Skelton.Once you have dispensed with any notion that the plot of Bathing Beauty bears no resemblance to reality, it is easy to sit back and accept the film as an amorphic assemblage of skits. Like many films of its era, it tries to jam as much entertainment into two hours as possible, utilizing the talent at hand. Bathing Beauty combines singing, dancing, comedy routines, pantomime, an aqua-routine reminiscent of Busby Berkeley including flaming water fountains, trumpet and organ solos, Stoogesque physical comedy, and Skelton's comedic touches that were the staple of his TV show for year to come.Esther Williams is, of course, beautiful. Some of the wardrobe she wears is amazing. Skelton is clever and his brand of physical comedy is sometimes silly, sometimes nearly poetic.The rest of the cast feels like a ensemble. They even put Harry James in a kick line. Jean Porter, a diminutive coed with spunk, plays a part usually given a name like "Jinx". She gives the film a shot of energy and vitality.Bathing Beauty does display a vibrant color palette. It's an attractive distraction from the war that Americans flocked to, and it's still a pleasant diversion today.

Red Skelton doesn't have to pander exhaustedly to an audience's collective funny bone for big laughs: his smudgy, rubbery face and double takes are amusing even when taken out of the screwball format. Here, director George Sidney has Skelton doing a ballet number complete with tutu, outwitting a Great Dane while dressed in drag, and mugging outrageously in a pantomime bit poking fun at a lady's morning ritual. All this while a reedy-thin plot--about a lovestruck man following his would-be wife to an all-girl college--plays out absentmindedly, with much of the emphasis on live bands, Latin American rhythms, singing and dancing, and organ music. There's also Esther Williams in and out of the swimming pool; her first major movie role as Skelton's true love was probably meant to show off her girlish pluck, yet she treats Red so poorly, he seems better off without her. Skelton, whose tight smile and worried little grimaces remind one of Robin Williams in his youth, is such an ingratiating presence that one can almost overlook the nastiness behind the narrative--that the entire faculty is against having him at the school and is conspiring to throw him out. The music helps plug up the holes, and the color production shimmers with that unmistakable 1940s glamor, but there are very few laughs here. *1/2 from ****

I was fourteen-years-old when this film was released and naturally eager to see the fabulous Esther Williams. However, I was totally mesmerized by Harry James, premier trumpeter of his day. His playing was absolutely dynamite. I had never heard anything like it. I made up my mind then and there that I wanted to do that. I went on to a successful trumpet-playing career largely due to the initial influence of the great James. In those days (Mid 1940's) everyone wanted to be a trumpet player (unlike the deluge of guitars today)mainly due to the influence of Harry James. I am impressed to this day whenever the film is shown on TV. For those of you unfamiliar with the film or of Harry James, I strongly recommend it, especially for young budding trumpet players.