Peg o' My Heart (1933)

Very well executed

Tied for the best movie I have ever seen

Am I Missing Something?

This is a coming of age storyline that you've seen in one form or another for decades. It takes a truly unique voice to make yet another one worth watching.

PEG O' MY HEART (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, 1933), directed by Robert Z. Leonard, stars Marion Davies in a comedy-drama adapted from the popular stage play that later developed into a 1922 silent screen adaptation for Metro starring Laurette Taylor. Though Taylor might have been considered reprising her legendary role she originated for the talking screen, it was an event that never happened. Being a tough act to follow for anyone else assuming the part, Davies contributes greatly in what many consider her finest screen performance. Though this MGM talkie edition resembles certain elements that makes this seem like one directed by John Ford over at the Fox Studios starring Janet Gaynor, Davies, however, shows her ability as an good actress from dancing the Irish jig to speaking in Irish brogue to fine credibility.The story opens on the West Coast of Ireland. Margaret, fondly known to all as "Peg" (Marion Davies), is introduced as a grown daughter of a fisherman father, Patrick Shamus O'Connell (J. Farrell MacDonald). Coming through the crowd in the fishing community is Sir Gerald Markham (Onslow Stevens), an executor of the Kingsnorth estate looking to speak with Mr. O'Connell. Markham informs O'Connell, whose late wife, Heather, being British by birth, that his father-in-law, Lord Brian Kingsnorth, has died and made Peg the sole heir of her mother's fortune of $2 million pounds. The will also specified that the only way Peg is to inherit the money is to spend three years living at the Chichester estate, with the separation between father and daughter to be permanent. At first O'Connell rejects the offer but eventually agrees to the terms following a tragic shipping accident. Promising to join her at a latter date, Peg agrees to leave her native Ireland with her dog, Michael, and Markham on the next train bound for England. Once at the Chichester estate, Peg finds her surroundings aren't as friendly as it is back home. During her stay, she copes with unfriendly servants and snobbish relatives. During the course of time, Peg has fallen in love with Markham, but is stunned to learn his wedding plans, arranged by Mrs. Chichester (Irene Browne), are to be to Ethel Chichester (Juliette Compton) and Peg's marriage to her foppish son, Alaric (Tyrell Davis). Knowing Ethel's unfaithfulness after witnessing her kissing Christian Brent (Alan Mowbray), a married man, Peg, wanting to return home, receives startling news from Markham as to why she can't return home and ever see her father again. Other members of the cast include: Doris Lloyd (Grace Brent); Robert Greig (Jarvis, the Butler); Geoffrey Gill (Terrence); Nora Cecil (Mrs. Smythe); Leyland Hodgson and Billy Bevan (The Detectives).Unlike the 1922 screen version, which includes a prologue of Peg as a child, PEG O' MY HEART eliminates the early origins of the O'Connells and death of the mother by getting right down to basics, making this 89 minute movie into a full-fledged Marion Davies product. Aside from sentimentality and moments of humor, there's also song interludes to such tunes as: "Sweetheart, Darlin'," "Safe at Home," "Just Remember That We Love You" (beautiful song), "Boots and Saddles,"Hoppity Hop," "Tavern in the Town," and several reprises of "Just Remember That We Love You"; "Sweetheart, Darlin'." Considering reprises of "Sweetheart, Darlin," not only is it Peg's favorite song in the story, but its theme song as well.Until it's occasional broadcasts on Turner Classic Movies from 1994 onward, PEG O' MY HEART was one of those rarely seen Marion Davies features for MGM of the 1930s in spite of its reputation as being Marion Davies best sound movie with SHOW PEOPLE (1928) as Davies' best silent. Yet, trite title songs as "Sweetheart, Darlin'" come across as mushy, or lack of a better known male co-star names as Robert Montgomery or Franchot Tone over Onslow Stevens may have something to do with its lack of any sort of revivals. With the exception of the familiarity of J. Farrell MacDonald, the lackluster cast shouldn't be the reason to avoid viewing this one either on Turner Classic Movies or acquiring a DVD copy for purchase to consider watching. Quite appropriate for St. Patrick's Day. (***)

I have never seen this movie before but I have heard of Marion Davies. I decided to give it a watch and I must admit I enjoyed it. I liked the lively Irish singing and dancing. To me the movie really highlighted the differences between the earthy Irish and the snotty English. I thought Marion Davies was pleasant surprise as Peg O'Connell although I did feel see was a wee bit old for the part (36). Michael the dog was pretty cool and J. Farrell McDonald was heartwarming as the old fisherman father. I also enjoyed how the English came across as cold- blooded and hypocritical. Obviously the film studio was relying heavily upon Hollywood stereotypes that would appeal to the Irish-American urban audience that this film was intended for in the first place.

What compels me to write a review on a film I have little enthusiasm for. Well, the rating IMDb has given this film for one thing. Another is the star of this film who seems to have a fervent following here. The synopsis has been covered many times so I will simply say it is a vehicle for Marion Davies to do her stuff.First of all I appreciate Marion's fans are willing to bump the rating up on this film but this is not an 8.1 movie as it is currently rated at IMDb. This was my first exposure to Marion Davies. This film is her show. She sings, she dances, she acts. I was not particularly impressed by her, except for a boundless energy she manages to carry throughout the film. And the fact the film moves along nicely and is never dull. I was wondering if I had missed something and gave the film to my wife to watch. She has a large collection of vintage musicals. Her opinion was more critical than mine. Marion can't sing, she can't dance and her acting is a little over the top.Now before all the Marion Davies fans tar and feather me, let me say this. This review is aimed more at people who are not familiar with her. Try a Marion Davies film out, maybe you will like her as many people do.

Marion Davies was given quite the acting challenge by MGM and her paramour William Randolph Hearst. In doing Peg O' My Heart she was taking on a role that was made immortal on stage and in a silent screen version by Laurette Taylor. But Marion was more than up to the challenge.In fact the film was the best of possible worlds for Davies. She could be the sweet heroine that Mr. Hearst always saw her as. But the part called for some singing and Irish dancing and Marion's great talents for mimicry. She's got the brogue down perfect, she really does sound like J. Farrell MacDonald's daughter and he came by his brogue naturally.The play was written for Laurette Taylor by her husband J. Hartley Manners and became Taylor's signature part. Davies did make it her own. The play was considerably expanded from the stage version which only takes place in the drawing room of the Chichester home in Great Britain.Young Peg O'Connell was the daughter of MacDonald and an English mother who left them because she couldn't stand the life in the fishing village in the west of Ireland. What's great for some is bad for others, the village looks and feels a whole lot like Innisfree where John Wayne couldn't wait to move to in The Quiet Man.But mom's died and she's left a will that says the Chichester family will be paid an installment to educate young Peg in proper English ways and then Peg's to receive a big inheritance. Looks like mom made out quite fine after she left J. Farrell MacDonald. Anyway she's also to cut off contact from her father completely.The usual English and Irish stereotypes circa 1912 when Peg O' My Heart opened on Broadway for a 603 performance run abound in the film version. Peg's presence however changes quite a few things in the lives of the Chichesters before she makes up her mind what her destiny is.Marion is just fine in the part, I certainly would like to know what Laurette Taylor might have thought of her performance.